Calculator FAQ
Asked & answered — including the awkward ones
The ‘why is my cash flow negative’ question, the ‘what’s a good return’ question, and the ‘what do you do with my data’ question. All of it, in plain English.
Using the calculator
Is this calculator really free, and do you collect my information?
Yes, and no. There is no email wall, no account, no cookies set by this site and no analytics. Every number you type stays in your browser, and the PDF report is generated on your own device. The only time anything leaves this site is when you choose to click through to Fairway’s secure systems to apply or upload documents.
Where do the default numbers come from?
They are a sample Twin Cities duplex scenario, chosen to be realistic rather than flattering: a non-homestead property-tax rate, a landlord insurance policy, a 5% vacancy allowance and a maintenance budget of 1% of value per year. Tax, insurance, maintenance and closing costs auto-scale with the purchase price until you type your own figure. The sample interest rate is an assumption, not a quote. Replace every one of them with figures from the actual listing, county records, an insurance quote and local rent comps.
What does the PDF report include?
The year-one headline metrics (cash flow, cap rate, cash-on-cash, DSCR and more), plain-English verdicts, the full purchase, financing, income and expense breakdown, and the investment analysis for your hold period — appreciation, principal paydown, cumulative cash flow, total return and CAGR. It adds a year-by-year annual cash flow table, a total-return chart and the disclosures, and it carries Tiaira’s contact details so you can forward it straight to her, your agent or a partner.
Can I save or share a scenario?
Download the PDF — that is the saved scenario. Because nothing is stored on a server, there is no account to log into and no scenario history; if you change a number, generate a fresh report.
The numbers
What is a good cash-on-cash return for a Minnesota rental?
Opinions vary, and the honest answer is “it depends what else you could do with the money.” Many investors target 6–10% cash-on-cash on a leveraged long-term rental, accept less for a property in a strong appreciation corridor, and want more for a heavy-rehab or rural deal. In today’s Twin Cities market, thin cash-on-cash with solid appreciation and principal paydown is common — which is why the calculator shows total return and CAGR, not just cash flow. None of these are promises; they are estimates built on the numbers you enter.
Why does the tool care so much about DSCR?
Because it is the number a DSCR loan is qualified on: gross monthly rent divided by the full monthly payment — principal, interest, taxes, insurance and HOA dues (PITIA). 1.00 means the rent exactly covers the payment, and 1.00 or higher typically qualifies with the best pricing; many programs allow lower ratios with adjustments. DSCR uses gross rent, so the calculator also shows NOI coverage: net operating income after vacancy, maintenance and management, divided by annual principal and interest. That is the stricter view commercial lenders and cautious investors use, and a cushion above 1.0× is what keeps a rental paying for itself in a bad month.
Why is my cash flow negative when the rent covers the mortgage?
Because the mortgage is not the only bill. Vacancy, maintenance, management, owner-paid utilities and capital repairs come on top of the payment, and together with property tax and insurance these costs typically eat 35–50% of rent on a Minnesota rental. That is why a property can show a DSCR of 1.00 or a bit higher and still lose money each month. The calculator deducts all of those before calling anything cash flow. A property that “covers the mortgage” but not the reserves will cash flow on paper and bleed the first time the furnace dies in January.
What’s the difference between cap rate and cash-on-cash?
Cap rate ignores financing: it is net operating income divided by purchase price, so it compares properties regardless of how they are bought. Cash-on-cash includes financing: it is annual cash flow after the mortgage divided by the cash you actually put in. Cap rate tells you about the property; cash-on-cash tells you about your deal.
Financing an investment property
How much do I need to put down on an investment property?
More than on a home you will live in. Conventional investment-property loans commonly require 15–25% down depending on the number of units, with 2–4 unit properties at the higher end, and DSCR purchases typically run 20–25% down. Rates typically run higher than owner-occupied pricing, and lenders usually want cash reserves after closing. If you plan to live in one unit of a 2–4 unit property, owner-occupied house-hack programs typically start at 3.5–5% down — ask Tiaira which program fits your deal.
What is a DSCR loan?
An investment-property loan that qualifies on the property’s rent divided by its full monthly payment (PITIA) instead of on your personal tax returns, W-2s or pay stubs. A ratio of 1.00 or higher typically qualifies, DSCR purchases typically run 20–25% down, and rates are typically higher than a conventional investor loan for the same borrower. It is a business-purpose loan for non-owner-occupied property — you can’t live in it. It is popular with self-employed investors, people buying in an LLC and anyone building a portfolio. Tiaira can price the same scenario as DSCR and conventional so you can compare.
Who is the loan officer behind this calculator?
Tiaira Quinn (NMLS #2568351), a loan officer with Fairway Home Mortgage, a dba of Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation (NMLS #2289). She is licensed in Minnesota, Wisconsin & North Dakota and focuses on DSCR and investor loans. Her name and contact details print on the PDF report, so you can send it straight to her. Nothing about your scenario is transmitted while you use the calculator — share the PDF only when you want her eyes on it.
Does this site give tax or legal advice?
No. Depreciation, passive-loss rules, Minnesota non-homestead classification, rental licensing and local rent-stabilization ordinances all affect real returns and all change — and Wisconsin and North Dakota have their own rules. The investor guide explains the concepts; a CPA and an attorney tell you how they apply to you.
Still wondering about something? Text Tiaira at 651-334-9049 — real questions get real answers, usually fast.
Questions about working with Tiaira, timing or LLCs are in the general FAQ. New to investing? Start with the Investor Playbook or the glossary, then run your numbers.
Investment calculator results and the downloadable report are estimates for illustrative and educational purposes only, based entirely on the figures you enter. They are not a quote, rate lock, pre-qualification, pre-approval, appraisal or commitment to lend, and they are not investment, tax or legal advice; accuracy is not guaranteed. Actual rates, payments, taxes, insurance, rents, vacancy, expenses and property values vary by property and scenario. Sample rates shown are assumptions, not an offer. Consult a licensed loan officer, tax professional and attorney before purchasing an investment property. Real estate investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Past appreciation and rent growth do not guarantee future results. Projections use constant annual growth rates you choose and do not account for income taxes, depreciation recapture, capital gains, refinancing, major repairs, or periods of extended vacancy.
Found a property? Run it by Tiaira.
Text her the address and the rent. You’ll get a straight read on whether it pencils as a DSCR deal — no pressure, no jargon, no obligation.